About the author: Nandika is an ambitious and compassionate student from Gurgaon, India. Currently enrolled in the 9th grade at The Shri Ram School, Moulsari, she is driven by a deep passion for making meaningful contributions to society. Inspired by her own experiences and a commitment to learning, she aspires to enrol in an undergraduate program in medicine, aiming to combine her love for science with a desire to create lasting change in healthcare.
Abstract
This research paper investigates the impact of health governance frameworks under the Ayushman Bharat scheme on healthcare access and outcomes in Jharkhand, an underserved state in India. Through a meticulous examination of enrolment data, service utilisation, geographical coverage, patient satisfaction and healthcare provider performance, the study evaluates the scheme’s efficacy. While the findings demonstrate significant improvements in healthcare access, they also reveal persistent challenges, particularly in ensuring equity for marginalised communities. The paper concludes with policy recommendations designed to improve the scheme’s implementation, thereby enhancing healthcare outcomes and ensuring more equitable access across Jharkhand.
Introduction
Ayushman Bharat, inaugurated by the Government of India in 2018 is a groundbreaking health insurance initiative aimed at extending financial protection to over 500 million economically vulnerable individuals. The program offers coverage for secondary and tertiary healthcare services with a limit of 500,000 Indian rupees per family per annum. This scheme is intended to mitigate the financial strain of healthcare expenses, which, according to a report by the Public Health Foundation of India, accounts for over 60% of household debt among low-income families in India (Kumar et al., 2021).
Jharkhand, characterised by a predominantly rural and tribal population, ranks among the lowest in India concerning healthcare indicators. The state’s infant mortality rate (IMR) stands at 30 per 1,000 live births, surpassing the national average of 28 (“National Family Health Survey-5, 2023). Moreover, over 60% of Jharkhand’s population resides in rural areas, where access to healthcare services is severely hampered by geographical isolation and substandard infrastructure.
How do health governance frameworks under Ayushman Bharat influence access to healthcare and social outcomes in Jharkhand? This study is pivotal in elucidating how the scheme influences healthcare access and outcomes in Jharkhand, offering critical insights into the program’s successes and challenges. The findings will serve as a valuable resource for policymakers striving to enhance healthcare delivery in underserved regions.
Current State of Healthcare Access in Jharkhand
Since its launch, Ayushman Bharat has successfully enrolled approximately 6.85 million beneficiaries in Jharkhand, with a significant majority originating from rural and tribal communities (National Health Authority, 2023). The scheme’s extensive outreach has resulted in 74% of the enrolled population residing in rural areas and 22% belonging to tribal communities (National Health Authority, 2023). However, disparities in enrolment rates persist, particularly among marginalised groups, where logical obstacles and a lack of awareness impede broader coverage.
Data from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare reveals that over 1.2 million hospital admissions have been registered under Ayushman Bharat in Jharkhand since 2018 (MoHFW, 2023). The most frequently accessed services include maternal healthcare (accounting for 34% of admissions), cardiovascular treatments (18%), and general surgery (16%). Despite these achievements, service utilisation remains inconsistent, with lower uptake observed in the most remote regions due to travel challenges and limited healthcare facilities.
Jharkhand’s challenging terrain exacerbates disparities in healthcare access. The state boasts only 0.52 healthcare facilities per 10,00 population in rural areas, compared to the national average of 1.04 (National Health Profile, 2022). Although Ayushman Bharat has facilitated the establishment of over 300 new healthcare centres, many remote areas continue to face significant accessibility challenges. For instance, in the Simdega district, patients often travel over 50 kilometres to reach the nearest hospital, resulting in delayed treatment and adverse health outcomes.
Surveys conducted by the Centre of Health Research indicate that 62% of beneficiaries in Jharkhand express satisfaction with the services provided under Ayushman Bharat, primarily due to the reduction in out-of-pocket expenses (Singh and Raj, 2023). However, 28% report dissatisfaction, citing issues such as prolonged wait times, inadequate facilities, and the unavailability of essential medicines. These mixed sentiments underscore the need for continuous monitoring and enhancement of service quality.
A comparative analysis of healthcare data pre- and post-Ayushman Bharat implementation reveals notable improvements in treatment outcomes. For example, Jharkhand’s maternal mortality ratio (MMR) has decreased from 165 per 100,000 live births in 2018 to 140 in 2023 (NFHS-5, 2023). Additionally, hospital readmissions for chronic illnesses have reduced by 15%, indicating better management and follow-up care under the scheme (MoHFW, 2023).
The performance of healthcare providers is integral to the scheme’s success. According to a 2022 audit by the National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, 78% of healthcare providers in Jharkhand adhere to the treatment protocols established under Ayushman Bharat. However, the audit also revealed significant variations in adherence rates, with districts such as Pakur and Sahibganj falling below 60% due to resource constraints and insufficient training (NIPFP, 2022).
Implementation Challenges
The enrolment process under Ayushman Bharat is beset by significant challenges, particularly in Jharkhand’s remote regions. A survey by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) found that 42% of eligible individuals in these areas were not enrolled due to a lack of awareness and difficulties in obtaining the necessary documentation (ICMR, 2022). Addressing these issues through targeted awareness campaigns and streamlining the enrolment process is crucial for achieving broader coverage.
Fraud prevention remains a critical challenge in the implementation of Ayushman Bharat. According to the National Health Authority, approximately 1.8% of claims filed under the scheme in Jharkhand were identified as fraudulent in 2022, resulting in losses exceeding INR 20 million (NHA, 2023). The use of technology, including biometric authentication and digital health records, has mitigated some of these risks, but continuous vigilance and more sophisticated fraud detection mechanisms are required.
Effective coordination between the central and state governments is vital for the successful implementation of Ayushman Bharat. However, a report by the Brookings Institution noted that inconsistencies in resource allocation and administrative responsibilities have led to delays in service delivery and inefficiencies in Jharkhand (Patel and Sharma, 2023). Enhanced communication and collaboration between the two levels of government are essential for overcoming these challenges and improving the scheme’s efficacy.
Impact on Health Infrastructure
Ayushman Bharat has significantly bolstered hospital infrastructure in Jharkhand, with over 150 healthcare facilities upgraded and 300 new centres established since 2018 (MoHFW, 2023). Despite these advancements, the state still requires additional investments to address ongoing infrastructure deficits, particularly in remote areas where access to healthcare remains constrained.
The healthcare workforce in Jharkhand has expanded under Ayushman Bharat, with the recruitment of 3,500 new healthcare workers, including doctors, nurses, and paramedics (NHA, 2023). However, challenges in staffing and skill development persist, particularly in rural and tribal areas. Continuous training and capacity-building efforts are essential to ensure that healthcare workers are adequately equipped to meet the population’s needs.
The integration of technology into healthcare delivery under Ayushman Bharat has been transformative. The use of telemedicine services has expanded access to specialised care, particularly in rural areas, with over 120,000 consultations conducted via telemedicine platforms in Jharkhand in 2023 (NHA, 2023). Additionally, the implementation of digital health records has streamlined service delivery and improved the efficiency of healthcare systems. However, disparities in technological adoption remain, with some regions benefiting more than others.
Policy Recommendations
To improve the enrolment process under Ayushman Bharat, the government should implement targeted awareness campaigns, particularly in tribal and rural areas. Simplifying documentation requirements and providing administrative support at the community level can also increase enrolment rates, ensuring that more individuals benefit from the scheme (Basu, 2024). Many potential beneficiaries, particularly in rural and tribal communities, remain unaware of the Ayushman Bharat scheme’s benefits or eligibility requirements. Conducting targeted awareness campaigns that are culturally sensitive and linguistically appropriate can help bridge this knowledge gap. Partnering with local influencers, community leaders, and healthcare workers can increase outreach effectiveness and credibility (Bhati et al, 2023). Using multimedia approaches, including radio, local television, community meetings, and mobile units for remote areas, can maximize reach.
Complex documentation requirements often discourage or prevent enrolment in the scheme. Streamlining these requirements, such as allowing for alternative forms of identification where standard documents are unavailable, can significantly ease access. Integrating biometric verification or mobile-based registration options may also facilitate quicker, more accessible enrolment processes, especially for those who lack physical documents or literacy skills. Establishing enrolment kiosks in local government offices, primary health centers, and mobile units dedicated to registration in rural or tribal regions can provide direct support to individuals (Sharma, Rohatgi, Jain and Singh, 2023). Training local administrative staff and community health workers on the enrolment process will equip them to assist with documentation and registration, reducing barriers for those unfamiliar with digital platforms or formal processes. These personnel can also act as local Ayushman Bharat ambassadors, building trust and familiarity within their communities.
Implementing a robust feedback mechanism that gathers input from enrolled and potential beneficiaries can help identify specific barriers to enrolment and improve the process over time. A system that allows beneficiaries to report issues through local representatives or mobile platforms ensures that the government receives timely information on enrolment challenges in remote areas, enabling them to make data-driven adjustments to the process (Joseph, Hari Sankar and Nambiar, 2021).
Additionally, to strengthen fraud detection under the Ayushman Bharat scheme, a multifaceted approach incorporating advanced data analytics, governance protocols, and robust oversight is essential. Advanced data analytics, including machine learning and predictive algorithms, can be a powerful tool for identifying patterns of fraudulent activity (Panda, 2019). By analysing large datasets across patient claims, provider behaviour, and billing records, the government can detect anomalies indicative of fraud, such as inflated treatment costs, unnecessary procedures, or duplicate claims. For instance, predictive analytics can flag high-risk providers or beneficiaries for review based on unusual billing patterns or deviations from regional healthcare norms (Bhattacharya, Madan Gopal and Garg, 2024).
Establishing a centralized, interoperable data platform that connects with various government databases (e.g., Aadhaar, health records, income databases) would allow cross-verification of beneficiary information, minimizing duplicate enrolments and identity fraud. This system can also integrate with other healthcare databases across states and regions, enabling a comprehensive view of beneficiary activities across different locations (Mishra, Yadav and Joe, 2024).
Introducing rigorous governance protocols is critical for accountability. Protocols such as mandatory pre-authorization for high-cost treatments, real-time monitoring of claims, and routine audits for healthcare providers and beneficiaries can deter fraudulent practices (Bhati et al, 2023). Additionally, establishing a risk-based audit approach that targets providers and beneficiaries with a higher likelihood of fraud can optimize the use of resources in overseeing the scheme. Regular training programs for personnel involved in claims processing, data analysis, and audits can improve the detection of fraudulent practices (Chauhan et al, 2022). Equipping these professionals with specialized skills in fraud detection, risk assessment, and analytical tools will enable them to effectively identify and address potential fraud cases. Partnerships with private sector firms or NGOs experienced in healthcare fraud detection could bring additional expertise and technological insights (Lahariya, 2018).
Improving coordination between the central and state governments is also essential for the successful implementation of Ayushman Bharat. This approach will help ensure that resources are optimally used, challenges are swiftly identified and addressed, and that both levels of government work collaboratively to achieve the scheme’s goals. Creating joint task forces composed of representatives from both central and state governments can provide a platform for continuous collaboration and localized decision-making (Kamath and Brand, 2023). These task forces can be set up at national, state, and district levels, each with defined roles in implementing, monitoring, and evaluating the scheme. State-level task forces can focus on adapting the program to regional contexts, while district task forces ensure last-mile delivery, especially in underserved rural and tribal areas.
A digital coordination portal accessible to both central and state authorities can improve data sharing and streamline communications. This portal could integrate real-time data on scheme performance, financial disbursements, provider networks, and beneficiary feedback, facilitating transparency and allowing both levels of government to monitor the scheme’s status at any time (Mishra, Yadav and Joe, 2024). Features like automated alerts for discrepancies in resource allocation or beneficiary enrolment can prompt quick intervention, ensuring timely responses to emerging issues. Differences in state-level protocols for implementation and resource allocation can sometimes lead to inconsistencies in beneficiary experience and healthcare delivery. Establishing standardized, adaptable guidelines can promote uniformity while allowing for local customization (Sahoo and Sriram, 2019). These guidelines might cover aspects like eligibility verification, claim processing, and reporting mechanisms, ensuring that the scheme’s core objectives are upheld while respecting state-specific needs.
Finally, ensuring equitable access to healthcare for all population groups, particularly marginalised and tribal communities, is a key priority. Ensuring equitable access to healthcare under the Ayushman Bharat scheme, particularly for marginalized and tribal communities, demands a focus on the unique barriers these groups face. Targeted interventions are essential to create a more inclusive healthcare system that addresses structural inequalities and promotes accessible, culturally sensitive healthcare (Chauhan et al, 2022).
Marginalized and tribal communities often face an information gap regarding available healthcare services and their eligibility under the Ayushman Bharat scheme. Deploying community health workers and local NGOs to conduct outreach in these communities can improve awareness and education. Materials and information sessions should be in local languages, using culturally relevant methods to make healthcare concepts accessible. Community events, interactive workshops, and mobile information units can further bridge the knowledge gap (Sharma, Rohatgi, Jain and Singh, 2023). Many tribal and marginalized communities reside in remote areas with limited healthcare infrastructure. Establishing mobile health units that can regularly visit these areas offers a way to bring services directly to underserved populations. These units could provide primary care, screening, enrolment services, and referrals, reducing the need for community members to travel long distances for healthcare (Mishra, Yadav and Joe, 2024). Mobile health services should ideally include staff who understand local languages and cultural nuances, fostering trust and engagement.
The enrolment process for Ayushman Bharat can be complex and may require documents that marginalized and tribal populations lack. Simplified enrolment procedures that allow alternative forms of identification, such as biometric verification or locally issued identity certificates, can make enrolment more accessible. Additionally, setting up enrolment support kiosks in tribal community centers or local government offices, staffed by trained personnel, can further ease the process (Joseph, Hari Sankar and Nambiar, 2021). Ensuring that healthcare providers understand the cultural and social context of marginalized and tribal communities can improve the quality of care and trust between patients and providers. Training programs on cultural sensitivity, communication styles, and traditional health beliefs can help providers deliver respectful, empathetic care. Involving local community members in healthcare teams as interpreters or cultural liaisons can also enhance mutual understanding and trust.
Involving representatives from tribal and marginalized communities in healthcare governance structures allows them to advocate for their communities’ needs directly. Including them in decision-making bodies, advisory panels, and regional health councils can ensure that healthcare policies and strategies reflect their unique needs (National Health Authority, 2023). This representation also allows the government to gather direct insights on barriers these groups face, making interventions more relevant and effective.
Conclusion
Ayushman Bharat has made substantial progress in enhancing healthcare access and outcomes in Jharkhand, particularly in rural and tribal areas. The scheme has facilitated increased enrolment, improved healthcare infrastructure, and expanded access to essential services. However, challenges persist, particularly in ensuring equitable access to healthcare for marginalised communities. The findings underscore the importance of addressing these challenges through targeted policy interventions and sustained investment in healthcare infrastructure and workforce development.
The findings of this study hold significant implications for healthcare policy and governance in India. They highlight the necessity for tailored interventions to address the unique challenges faced by underserved regions like Jharkhand. Strengthening coordination between the central and state governments and promoting equity in healthcare access are critical for the successful implementation of large-scale health initiatives like Ayushman Bharat.
Future research should focus on long-term health outcomes under Ayushman Bharat and explore the impact of complementary healthcare policies. Additional studies could investigate the effectiveness of specific interventions aimed at improving healthcare access and equity in underserved regions.
References
- Basu, Rumki. “The Ayushman Bharat Programme in India.” Indian Journal of Public Administration 70, no. 2 (2024): 413-418.
- Bhati, Akshaya Nidhi, Arun Kumar, Mehedi Masud, and Dac-Nhuong Le. “An Overview of Healthcare Policy in India for Designing New Customised Health Services for the Patient.” 5G-Based Smart Hospitals and Healthcare Systems (2023): 46-62.
- Bhattacharya, Sudip, K. Madan Gopal, and Suneela Garg. “Sustaining Current Policies and Introducing New Initiatives: Strategic Five-year Plan for the Government of India.” Journal of the Epidemiology Foundation of India 2, no. 3 (2024): 134-143.
- Chauhan, Vishal, Neha Dumka, Erin Hannah, Tarannum Ahmed, and Atul Kotwal. “Recent initiatives for transforming healthcare in India: A political economy of health framework analysis.” Journal of Global Health Economics and Policy 2 (2022): e2022002.
- “ICMR Survey on Ayushman Bharat Enrollment in Remote Regions.” Indian Council of Medical Research, 2022.
- Joseph, Jaison, Hari Sankar D, and Devaki Nambiar. “Empanelment of health care facilities under Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB PM-JAY) in India.” PloS one 16, no. 5 (2021): e0251814.
- Kamath, Rajesh, and Helmut Brand. “A critical analysis of the world’s largest publicly funded health insurance program: India’s Ayushman Bharat.” International Journal of Preventive Medicine 14, no. 1 (2023): 20.
- Kumar, Abhishek, et al. “Healthcare Access and Financial Burden in India: Evidence from the National Sample Survey.” Public Health Foundation of India, vol. 45, no. 2, 2021, pp. 120-130.
- Lahariya, Chandrakant. “‘Ayushman Bharat’program and universal health coverage in India.” Indian Pediatrics 55, no. 6 (2018): 495-506.
- Mishra, Udaya Shankar, Suryakant Yadav, and William Joe. “The Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission of India: An Assessment.” Health Systems & Reform 10, no. 2 (2024): 2392290.
- “National Family Health Survey-5 (NFHS-5).” Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, 2023.
- “Ministry of Tribal Affairs Annual Report 2022.” Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India, 2022.
- “National Health Authority Report 2023.” National Health Authority, Government of India, 2023.
- “National Health Profile 2022.” Central Bureau of Health Intelligence, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, 2023.
- “National Sample Survey Office Report 2023.” Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, Government of India, 2023.
- “National Institute of Public Finance and Policy Audit Report 2022.” NIPFP, 2022.
- Panda, Pradeep Kumar. “Ayushman Bharat: Challenges and Way Forward.” Future of FinTech: Innovative Business Model for Financial Inclusion 89 (2019): 1-7.
- Patel, Mukesh, and Ravi Sharma. “Coordinating Healthcare Policies in India: Lessons from Ayushman Bharat.” Brookings Institution India Report, 2023.
- Sahoo, Manoj K., and D. Sriram. “Agility in Governance through Public Health Initiatives: The Case of India’s Ayushman Bharat-National Health Protection Mission.” GNLU JL Dev. & Pol. 9 (2019): 25.
- Sharma, R. S., Aishwarya Rohatgi, Sandeep Jain, and Dilip Singh. “The Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM): making of India’s digital health story.” CSI Transactions on ICT 11, no. 1 (2023): 3-9.
- Singh, Suraj, and Anil Raj. “Patient Satisfaction under Ayushman Bharat: A Study in Jharkhand.” Centre for Health Research, 2023, pp. 40-55.