About the author:
Navyaa is a diligent and passionate student of health policy who is currently studying in the 10th grade at The Shri Ram School, Gurugram. Coming from a family of doctors, Navyaa is aware of contemporary health problems in India. She wants to actively contribute towards society and make a positive change within prevailing conditions. She aspires to pursue a legal career in the health sector in the future.
Abstract
Despite a high burden of organ failure, India’s organ donation rate remains substantially low compared to global standards. This research paper explores the multifaceted barriers hindering the expansion of organ donation across the country. This qualitative study identifies cultural, regulatory, infrastructural, and awareness-related challenges as the primary impediments. Cultural hesitancy, deeply rooted in religious and familial beliefs, prominently influences the reluctance towards organ donation. Regulatory complexities and the lack of a streamlined process exacerbate the situation, creating bureaucratic delays that deter potential donors. The paper proposes targeted policy interventions, including educational campaigns, streamlined legal procedures, and enhanced healthcare infrastructure, to improve the organ donation rate in India. These recommendations aim to create a robust framework that increases organ donation rates and ensures ethical practices and equitable organ distribution.
Introduction
Organ transplantation is a critical life-saving intervention for patients suffering from end-stage organ failure (Horton & Horton, 1991). While medical advancements have significantly improved transplantation outcomes, the gap between the number of organs needed and those available continues to widen, particularly in developing countries like India. Despite a population exceeding 1.3 billion, India faces a paradoxically low rate of organ donation compared to global figures (Ahlawat et al, 2013). This disparity highlights an urgent need to address the systemic and cultural barriers that limit organ donation in the country.
The importance of organ donation cannot be overstated, as it not only saves lives but also enhances the quality of life for recipients and creates profound ethical and social impact in a community. It is a means of encouraging people to contribute positively to society by helping others in dire need. India has a significant demand for organ transplants, driven by high incidence rates of conditions like diabetes, hypertension, and chronic liver and kidney diseases (Feeley & Servoss, 2005). These diseases can often result in organ failures that necessitate transplants to save those lives.
Additionally, there is a large gap between the number of organs needed and the organs available for transplantation. This gap results in long waiting lists, with many patients dying while waiting for a transplant (Gorczyca & Hartman, 2017). At the same time, effective organ donation and transplantation can significantly reduce long-term healthcare costs associated with chronic disease management by providing a more permanent solution compared to a long-term treatment. In this sense, for many recipients organ transplants mean a drastic improvement in the quality of their lives (Hair et al, 2017). Transplants can often offer patients a second chance at life, enabling them to return to normal activities and reducing their dependence on medical and family support.
However, the process of organ donation and transplantation is encumbered by a range of barriers. These include cultural and religious misconceptions, lack of awareness, inadequate healthcare infrastructure, and complex regulatory frameworks, all of which contribute to the underutilization of potential organ donors. Furthermore, insufficient infrastructure, especially in rural and semi-urban areas, limits the effective procurement and transplantation of organs. Lastly, a pervasive lack of awareness about organ donation mechanisms and benefits is identified as a significant barrier (Kute et al, 2020).
This paper aims to systematically explore these barriers through a comprehensive review of existing literature across various Indian states. This study seeks to paint a holistic picture of the current challenges. The objective is to propose actionable policy interventions that could significantly enhance the organ donation rate in India. Through this research, we intend to contribute to the ongoing efforts to develop a more effective and equitable organ transplantation system, ultimately improving public health outcomes across the country.
The Critical Role of Policy Frameworks in Enhancing Organ Donation in India
Effective policy frameworks ensure that the process of organ donation and transplantation is conducted ethically and legally. This includes safeguarding donor and recipient rights, preventing illegal organ trade, and ensuring that all practices adhere to established medical standards. Clear policies help build trust in the donation system among the general public, which is crucial for increasing participation (Mekahli et al, 2009).
India has one of the lowest organ donation rates in the world despite having a high demand for organ transplants. Well-designed policies can address various barriers to organ donation, such as lack of awareness, religious and cultural hesitations, and misconceptions about the medical process (Mohan et al, 2020). For example, policies promoting educational campaigns can significantly improve public understanding and acceptance of organ donation.
India’s current policy framework for organ donation is primarily governed by the Transplantation of Human Organs Tissues Act (THOTA), initially enacted in 1994 and subsequently amended. This act regulates the removal, storage and transplantation of human organs and tissues for therapeutic purposes with a strong emphasis on ethical practices to prevent commercialization. Key aspects of the policy include promoting both deceased and living organ donations, albeit with stringent regulations to ensure that ethical compliance and voluntary consent remain in place. Living donors are defined as family members or close relatives by the legislation, although the concept of swap transplants among incompatible donor-recipient pairs was introduced in the 2011 amendment. Despite these advancements, challenges persist, such as infrastructural deficiencies, legal barriers, and ethical dilemmas that hinder the organ donation process (Patthi et al, 2015). The Apex Swap Transplant Registry facilitates swap transplantations in India, where incompatible donor-recipient pairs can swap donors to match compatible pairs. This is particularly useful in overcoming biological incompatibilities in kidney and liver transplants.
The National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organization (NOTTO) plays a crucial role in overseeing and facilitating organ donations across India, aiming to ensure equitable and efficient distribution and utilization of organs (Ramadurg & Gupta, 2014). It serves as the central body for all activities related to procurement, distribution and allocation of organs and tissues in India. It operates as the primary entity for coordination and networking for procurement and distribution of organs and tissues across the country (Patthi et al, 2015). Establishing guidelines and protocols that harmonize with global standards to ensure fair and ethical practices in organ donation in India, NOTTO also works towards increasing public awareness and managing national registries to streamline the donation process.
Additionally, State Organ and Tissue Transplant Organizations (SOTTOs) are state-level organizations that are responsible for the implementation of organ donation and transplantation policies within their respective states. They work closely in coordination with NOTTO to ensure that policies and procedures are uniformly applied across different regions, thereby facilitating a streamlined organ donation process (Kute et al, 2020). Furthermore, Regional Organ and Tissue Transplant Organization (ROTTO) serves broader regions by acting as intermediaries between NOTTO and SOTTOs. They help to manage the logistics and coordination of organ donations across multiple state, playing a critical role in the inter-state transfer and allocation of organs.
Policy Recommendations
Robust policy frameworks are essential for enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the organ donation and transplant system in India. They play a pivotal role in overcoming existing challenges and ensuring that the life-saving potential of organ donation can be fully realized, benefiting a larger segment of the population in need (Chung et al, 2008). Policies can facilitate the development of necessary infrastructure for organ retrieval, preservation, and transplantation. This includes creating more transplant centers and improving transport and storage facilities, which are especially needed in rural and remote areas. Effective policy implementation ensures that all regions have equitable access to transplant services, thus maximizing the use of available organs (Ramadurg & Gupta, 2014).
Stronger policies are needed to ensure that organs are allocated in a fair, transparent, and efficient manner. This includes creating and maintaining a centralized database for organ recipients and developing criteria that prioritize organ distribution based on medical need, compatibility, and other ethical considerations (Gorczyca & Hartman, 2017). A clear policy framework can streamline the organ donation process, making it easier for families to consent to donation and for medical professionals to facilitate the procedure. This includes standardized protocols for organ retrieval, preservation, and transportation.
With the global nature of health challenges, policy frameworks in India could align with international standards and practices, facilitating cross-border cooperation in organ donation and transplantation. This is particularly important for rare cases that require highly specialized treatments available in different countries (Horton & Horton, 1991).
The government can promote policies for research and innovation in the field of organ donation and transplantation. Supporting research into new technologies, such as improved preservation techniques or alternative solutions like organ fabrication from stem cells, can address the shortage of available organs (Ahlawat et al, 2013). Therefore, the government must allocate funding for research in organ preservation, transplantation techniques, and post-transplant care to improve success rates and outcomes. The development and adoption of innovative technologies and practices to enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of organ donation and transplantation must also be promoted by the government.
Effective policy frameworks enable a rapid and coordinated response in situations where there are opportunities for multiple organ donations (such as after accidents), ensuring that organs are quickly and effectively harvested and transplanted. Where possible, policies must be designed and implemented for programs to honor and recognize donors and their families, fostering a positive public perception of organ donation (Mekahli et al, 2009). Simultaneously, incentives must be provided to hospitals and healthcare professionals to encourage participation in organ donation and transplantation programs. Finally, the government must collaborate with various NGOs and civil society organizations to conduct awareness campaigns aimed at educating the public about the importance of organ donation. These campaigns should focus on dispelling myths and encouraging people to register as donors. For example, expanding on the awareness campaign led by NOTTO called ‘Pledge Your Organs’ would be an effective measure for addressing this policy challenge (Kute et al, 2020). This campaign encouraged individuals to pledge their organs for donation by signing up through an online portal (Tamuli et al:, 2019). The campaign is supported by various promotional activities, including media advertisements, events, and collaborations with celebrities to reach a broader audience. Similarly, the ‘Ang Daan’ campaign focused on raising awareness about the importance of eye donation (Patthi et al, 2015). It included public service announcements and educational programs that highlighted the impact of cornea donations in restoring sight to the visually impaired.
Conclusion
The role of organ donation in India is critical, given the life-saving potential it holds and the number of people it can benefit. However, most Indians remain uninformed of the legislation or policy framework around organ donation processes in India. Several research studies have indicated that the willingness of the donor to engage with the family of the person receiving the transplant played a crucial role in strengthening the intent of the donor to donate the organ – an insight that should be explored further (Feeley & Servoss, 2005). The general mindset and attitude towards organ donation also differs based on the education levels of people. This situation highlights the need for governmental and non-governmental institutions to take up the mandate of creating awareness that could lead to bridging the demand-supply gap of organs in India. By enhancing the framework for organ donation and making it a norm rather than an exception, India can address critical healthcare challenges effectively.
References
- Ahlawat R, Kumar V, Gupta AK, et al.: Attitude and knowledge of healthcare workers in critical areas towards deceased organ donation in a public sector hospital in India. The National Med. J. India. 2013;26(6):322–326.
- Chung CK, Ng CW, Li JY, et al.: Attitudes, knowledge, and actions with regard to organ donation among Hong Kong medical students. Hong Kong Med. J. 2008;14(4):278–285.
- Feeley TH, Servoss TJ: Examining college students’ intentions to become organ donors. J. Health Commun. 2005;10(3):237–249. Global overview report. 10.1080/10810730590934262
- Gorczyca M, Hartman RL: The new face of philanthropy: The role of intrinsic motivation in millennials’ attitudes and intent to donate to charitable organizations. J. Nonprofit Publ. Sect. Market. 2017;29(4):415–433. 10.1080/10495142.2017.1326349
- Hair JF, Jr, Sarstedt M, Ringle CM, et al.: Advanced issues in partial least squares structural equation modeling. Sage Publications;2017b.
- Horton R, Horton P: A model of willingness to become a potential organ donor. Soc. Sci. Med. 1991;33:1037–1051. 10.1016/0277-9536(91)90009-2
- Kute V, Ramesh V, Shroff S, et al.: Deceased-donor organ transplantation in India: current status, challenges, and solutions. Exp. Clin. Transplant. 2020;18(Suppl 2):31–42. 10.6002/ect.rlgnsymp2020.L6
- Mekahli D, Liutkus A, Fargue S, et al.: Survey of first-year medical students to assess their knowledge and attitudes toward organ transplantation and donation. Transplantation proceedings. Elsevier;2009, March; (Vol.41(No.2): pp.634–638). 10.1016/j.transproceed.2008.12.011
- Mohan L, Thanga T, Selvam P: Perspective on organ donation in India: a comprehensive review. J. Community Heal Manag. 2020;7(3):73–76. 10.18231/j.jchm.2020.017
- National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation: Act and rules of transplant of human organs act (THOA).
- Patthi B, Jain S, Singla A, et al.: Beliefs and barriers for organ donation and influence of educational intervention on dental students: A questionnaire study. J. Indian Assoc. Public Health Dent. 2015;13(1):58. 10.4103/2319-5932.153588
- Pouraghaei M, Tagizadieh M, Tagizadieh A, et al.: Knowledge and attitude regarding organ donation among relatives of patients referred to the emergency department. Emergency. 2015;3(1):33–39.
- Ramadurg UY, Gupta A: Impact of an educational intervention on increasing the knowledge and changing the attitude and beliefs towards organ donation among medical students. J. Clin. Diagn. Res. 2014;8(5):JC05–JC07. 10.7860/JCDR/2014/6594.4347
- Tamuli RP, Sarmah S, Saikia B: Organ donation–“attitude and awareness among undergraduates and postgraduates of North-East India”. J. Family Med. Prim Care. 2019;8(1):130. 10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_206_18